Well, the haircut that got the most votes was #4 by a landslide.
I had an appointment this weekend with Alex Billingsley. Who I officially love, by the way. He was talking to me about the Brazillian Blowout hair straightening treatment. While I was there, showed him the blog, and my options for haircuts. I wanted his opinion as a professional. I asked him what he would recommend for my face shape and hair type, and he said he wouldn't cut it. He said that he would like to change up my layers and by adding some shorter ones around my face it would give me more definition and movement. So I think I'm going to try that before making the move to chop off a good two feet of hair.
So that is the plan! I know deep in my heart that this haircut (#4) will be mine some day. But I think that at this point in my life emotionally, I need to keep my long hair as a tie to myself. It's so easy to lose "me" in this crazy whirlwind that is life and motherhood that I think keeping this one "me" thing will help keep me stable.